Carrie Underwood's Controversial Clip Resurfaces, Sparkling Debate Over Her ‘American Idol’ Legacy

Carrie Underwood's highly anticipated return to "American Idol" has stirred unexpected controversies, overshadowing the excitement of her homecoming. As a notable alum from season four, Underwood now judges alongside Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan in the show's 23rd season, which began in March. Recent reports highlight tensions regarding the Easter special, "Songs of Faith," which Underwood pushed for but some crew members felt was inappropriate. Critics are voicing concerns about her influence on the show's legacy, while her controversial past, including backlash for attending Trump's inauguration, has further fueled dissent.