Shocking Moment: Off-Duty Pennsylvania Police Chief Draws Gun on Motorcyclist Over Minor Traffic Infraction

As Benny Pena-Rivera, 24, rode his motorcycle to his job at Wingstop in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, he noticed an unfamiliar vehicle closely trailing him. Unbeknownst to Pena-Rivera, it was Duane Fisher, the off-duty Manheim Township police chief, who—without proper identification—approached him moments later. Instead of a courteous introduction, Fisher emerged from his unmarked car brandishing his firearm, commanding Pena-Rivera onto the ground. Pena-Rivera recounted the encounter, questioning Fisher's method of approach as he felt threatened. Captured on surveillance, the confrontation escalated, leading Pena-Rivera to flee while Fisher activated his sirens post-haste. Following his arrest the next day, numerous charges against Pena-Rivera were dismissed. An internal review of Fisher's conduct is underway as he faces suspension with pay. Pena-Rivera’s experience has left him uneasy around law enforcement.